From the full archive.

⤺ Browse all writings instead

Can God Be Correcting Me Without Punishing Me?

Yes. He can. He does it constantly, and most of us have never learned to recognize it as anything but anger.

Something in you is uneasy. A conversation will not leave you alone. A habit that used to feel fine now feels heavy. And immediately the old fear stands up: God is upset with me.

Sit down a moment. Let me show you the difference between the voice that corrects and the voice that condemns.

Correction comes with an invitation. Condemnation comes with a verdict.

When God corrects you, He is specific and He is near. There is something to do, and He is standing right there while you do it.

Condemnation is vague and it is far away. It does not tell you what to fix. It tells you what you are. It does not say this was wrong. It says you are wrong, and you always have been.

One hands you a towel. The other hands you a sentence.

The basin and the towel

In John 13, Jesus does the most correcting thing in the Gospels, and He does it kneeling with a basin of water.

He does not shame the feet. He washes them. He tells Peter plainly that unless He washes him, Peter has no part with Him — and Peter, being Peter, asks for a bath.

That is what correction looks like in the hands of God. It is close, it is honest, it is kind, and it leaves you cleaner than it found you.

Why correction has to feel like something

It would not be correction if it were comfortable. Hebrews 12:11 says no discipline seems pleasant at the time, but later it produces a harvest of righteousness and peace for those trained by it.

Later. Trained. Harvest. Those are not the words of a courtroom. They are the words of a farm and a family.

Four ways to tell them apart

Correction is specific; condemnation is global. Correction points to an action; condemnation points at your soul.

Correction leaves hope; condemnation leaves paralysis. After correction there is a next step. After condemnation there is only weight.

Correction draws you toward God; condemnation drives you away from Him. Adam hid. That was not God's idea.

Correction ends; condemnation loops. God says a thing once and then helps you carry it out. The voice that repeats the same accusation for ten years is not His.

What to do with it

Take the specific thing. Do the specific thing. Then let it be finished, because 1 John 1:9 says it is finished the moment you bring it into the light.

You do not have to be afraid of a God who corrects you. Only a Father who intends to keep you bothers to correct you at all. He is not building a case. He is raising a child.


Go Deeper

If this question is living in you right now, I wrote a short book about it. When Fire Does Not Consume: It Transforms is free to read, and so is How Jesus Faced Gethsemane.

— Marty Gool

Still wondering if God is punishing you?

Read next: God’s Discipline: What It Looks Like and What It Feels Like

Read the Next Article

Not sure where to begin? Start Here